Shifting Focus in Today's Boardrooms: Executive Talent Expertise As the Missing Piece

The Shifting Focus in Today's Boardrooms: Why Executive Talent Expertise is the Missing Piece

The New Boardroom Reality

Remember when financial oversight, compliance, and quarterly results dominated board agendas? That world is gone. Today, nearly every board conversation I'm part of eventually circles back to people issues.

Today, nearly every board conversation eventually circles back to people issues.

What Boards Are Grappling With

Here's what I'm hearing in these conversations:

"Our CEO just resigned with barely a month's notice." This leadership volatility is happening everywhere – CEO tenure has shrunk to about 5 years, and other C-suite roles are even less stable. One chair told me, "We spend more time grappling with succession scenarios than discussing our actual business strategy."

"We thought we had our leadership pipeline figured out, then our industry started transforming." The skills that built yesterday's success often don't match tomorrow's challenges. Many companies have to completely rethink what leadership looks like as their sector boundaries blur.

"Our biggest investors are asking pointed questions about our executive team that we struggle to answer confidently." I'm seeing major investors explicitly evaluating boards on whether they have the expertise to build and maintain exceptional leadership teams.

"Our company culture used to be HR's responsibility, now it's a regular board agenda item." Company culture has become a strategic advantage that boards can't ignore. Directors now need to ensure leadership teams can create environments where performance and wellbeing thrive together.

The Adaptation Challenge

What fascinates me is watching how boards are (or aren't) adapting. Most still recruit new directors primarily for industry experience, functional expertise or financial knowledge. Sure - those things matter, but they're not addressing these new challenges.

I am convinced that the boards that are thriving through this uncertainty are the ones deliberately evolving their composition to include expertise that directly tackles these emerging issues. I've been thinking about expertise that's consistently missing from boards despite its significant impact on performance.

Most boards still recruit new directors primarily for industry experience, functional expertise or financial knowledge.

Executive Talent Expertise: The Board Skill Worth Adding

Here's what I've noticed: most boards have financial experts, industry veterans, and tech-savvy directors – but very few have someone who is a real expert in executive talent. This seems strange to me. We all know having the right leaders and the right culture makes or breaks a company's future. Yet boards rarely include members who are truly skilled at spotting, assessing, and developing great leaders.

Most boards have financial experts, industry veterans, and tech-savvy directors – but very few have someone who is a real expert in executive talent.

I was interested to read a McKinsey study that found companies with this expertise on their board did 22% better in shareholder returns. That's not just a nice-to-have – that's serious competitive edge.

What This Expertise Actually Looks Like

What does this expertise actually look like? It's the board member who:

• Has years of experience finding and evaluating top executive talent, beyond simple recruiting

• Can be a trusted advisor and sparring partner to the CEO during important leadership changes and transitions

• Can see what leadership skills will be needed in the next 3-5-10 years

• Knows how to judge if leaders can handle future challenges, not just past successes

• Can quickly and instinctively spot leadership and talent patterns that either help or hurt company strategy

Boards with this expertise make much better decisions about their leaders. This goes far beyond regular talent management. It's about having someone who can tell whether your leadership team can actually deliver on your biggest goals and who can create the ideal strategic talent architecture to ensure capability building for the future.

Boards with executive talent expertise make much better decisions about their leaders.

So here's my question for you: When was the last time your board looked for a director with specific executive talent expertise? If the answer is "never," you might be missing one of your most powerful tools for success.

---

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

• Marion Heil is the founder and managing director of Board+CEO Advisors. She is based in Vienna.